IMBALANCE OF COMMITMENT AMONG SIGNATORY STATES: PROBLEMATICS OF RATIFICATION IN THE NUCLEAR ARMS CONTROL REGIME
Keywords:
Nuclear Arms Control; Ratification; Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty; International Treaty Law.Abstract
The imbalance in ratification commitments among states poses significant challenges to the effectiveness and implementation of international nuclear arms control treaties, particularly the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty (CTBT), which has not entered into force despite widespread international support. This study focuses on the legal consequences of nonratification and Russia's revocation of CTBT ratification in 2023, as well as the institutional roles of international organizations in addressing these challenges. It aims to analyze the implications of unequal ratification for treaty effectiveness, international legal obligations, and nuclear arms control governance. Employing normative legal research, this study applies treaty-based, conceptual, and case approaches through qualitative analysis of international legal instruments, official institutional documents, and scholarly literature. The findings demonstrate that the failure of designated states to ratify the CTBT prevents its entry into force and limits the activation of its complete verification mechanisms, although preparatory monitoring arrangements remain operational. Russia's revocation of ratification further illustrates the strategic use of treaty participation while raising questions concerning previously expressed consent and continuing obligations associated with signature. Nevertheless, nonratification does not automatically constitute a breach of international law. The study also finds that the CTBTO Preparatory Commission, International Atomic Energy Agency, and United Nations support nuclear arms control through distinct institutional mandates, but cannot substitute for the consent required for treaty entry into force.


